The Sunday Independent reported yesterday on the infamous “Kilkenny trust” that supposedly allows you to scrub a property free of bank debt, as if by magic. It was reported earlier in the Summer that certain business people, including Bill Cullen, were using the mechanism.
Given the privacy of the operation it is difficult to ascertain from news reports what has been going on but, helpfully, Karl Deeter attended a presentation about the scheme and has blogged about it here. I am not a trust specialist but, in my professional opinion, it looks mad.
I had a few questions of my own reading the post:
- Why are they recruiting people to enter into the trust? Usually, legal and accounting mechanisms are put in place by a combination of accountants and solicitors to help their clients achieve a certain goal. It is unusual for non-professionals to go about recruiting people to join a scheme like this and, as Karl points out, the don’t seem to have professional indemnity insurance to protect clients when things go wrong. However, I note that they charge a fee themselves.
- They get you to set up “a private trust in private”. What does the second use of the word private achieve?
- What is meant by getting a notary to create a “Court of Record”? I’ll tell you: nothing. It makes no sense. A court of record is a court, and notaries don’t “create” courts. In fact, the only notaries in Ireland are notaries public who are only involved in transactions with an international dimension. There is no international dimension to these transactions so a notary should not be involved. The most an Irish notary public might do is verify some document or signature but, again, a notary public only does this for use abroad and a solicitor or commissioner for oaths would suffice.
- They say that only your folio number goes into the trust. This makes no sense. A folio number is a record number for registered property and has no life or value apart from the property. You couldn’t sell or rent your folio number separately from the property, so how could you transfer it into a trust on its own?
Most of the rest of what they say involves banking and mortgages and Karl has pointed out that it doesn’t add up. I’m sure other solicitors and barristers would notice flaws in the proposal by reading his post (comments welcome here too). Karl reaches the sad but unavoidable conclusion:
This has all of the hallmarks of something that is either ‘too good to be true’ or perhaps ill thought out and where the absence of a challenge to date is being taken as evidence that ‘it works’ which is not how the legal system operates. The moving of an asset to a trust doesn’t mean a legal charge suddenly doesn’t exist, it doesn’t mean that there was never a lien or a contract between two parties, if using trusts to stop creditors was that simple we probably would have heard of it before now.
Of the people at the meeting none of them seemed highly literate financially, several disclosed that they were borrowers of sub-prime lenders and the common thread was that they were all vulnerable and perhaps willing to believe something too easily, because I have learned from experience that when a person is drowning that even if you throw them a rock and say it will float that they are willing to give it a try.
3 thoughts on “Stop the madness”
It seems to me that this “trust” might be considered a conveyance intended to defraud creditors under s 74(3) of the Land and Conveyancing Reform Act 2009. If so, it is “voidable”, at the instance of the affected creditor. Furthermore, I cannot see how the proponents of the trust can claim it puts any property beyond the reach of the courts.
And look at clause 3(b) of the trust deed: http://www.mortgagebrokers.ie/blog/debt-reduction/let-the-bullshit-begin-the-document-behind-the-kilkenny-trust/
The ‘Court of Record’ business is a Freeman trope: see this if you head can withstand the barrage of [ponders appropriate term] Self-Taught Scholarship.
It seems that most US Courts are formed under Admiralty Law, while European and British ones are constituted by Canon Law. It must be true – he says so in his video!
In the face of such olympian intellects, how can you question the efficacy of the Kilkenny Trust people?
You at the back! Yes, you!: STOP THAT SNICKERING!!
Comments are closed.